Do Supercontrol Toggles Work Correctly?

Question

I think this bug is surely related to the erratic behaviour of radio buttons.

If I set up a toggle button to be a super and set the control to  send the on value only then in the case that the midi range of this super is 0 to 127 everything is OK. If the range is non zero for both sides and despite the fact that super is supposed to send the on value only to the sub, actually both values are send to the sub. e.g values 1 to 127 will move the sub in both the open and the closed stated of the button.

I don't know if this has always been the the behaviour of toggles but it definetaly isn't right. I've got too many problems when I try to use radio buttons and manipulate other controls in series.

Comments

No reason to revert to exciting titles to get our attention, like "definately [sic] a bug!"... We take all Q&A questions seriously, but give priority to those that are stated in a neutral way. Thanks!

---

You are correct that the behavior of toggle supercontrols with a non-zero minimum and "send on only" is odd... if the minimum is not zero, the min sends anyway.

However: why would you set the minimum to something other than zero, since it's not going to send anyway?

We're trying to understand the use-case for this before we consider it a bug. Until we do, it's just an oddity.

Thanks for your continued enthusiasm for MD.

Best!
Dan

---

Hey Dan thx for your support and sorry for indeed being overxcited about this. Have to say that I am having a very hard time to tame the radio toggles and I was thinking that this maybe a clue for something.
Anyway you are possibly right,  its just an odd behavior that doesn't feel right to me.
Would you like to continue a dialogue here about the radio toggles or would it be better to mail u from the app.

---

Thanks, no worries whatsoever, it just gives me a small heart attack to see titles like that ;)

Please email me from the app for this stuff... and then we'll come back to the forums as need be. The emails come through the support interface, which is a lot more flexible for us.

Thanks!
Dan